Enjoy Comfort Food with Olivia’s Take Out

We’re rediscovering lots of food favorites as many Disney resort restaurants are offering to-go and take out food. We’ve been gushing about ordering to go from Sanaa via the MyDisneyExperience app. While we wait, and hope, for other Disney resort restaurants to expand mobile ordering, let’s revisit a fan favorite that does not get enough attention: Olivia’s at Disney’s Old Key West Resort.

Enjoy Comfort Food with Olivia’s Take Out © Sarah Graffam
© Sarah Graffam

Our readers rate Olivia’s with a 92% thumbs up, and it is ranked at 21 out of 103 table service restaurants at Walt Disney World. Olivia’s is the hometown favorite of Old Key West. Opening with the resort back in 1991, Olivia’s is a place that holds decades of memories for Disney Vacation Club members.

The interior dining room feels like visiting your retired grandparents at their island home down in the Florida Keys. Homely décor mixed with old Florida tropical touches creates an atmosphere only Old Key West could provide.

Enjoy Comfort Food with Olivia’s Take Out
Olivia’s dining room (pre-COVID)

Open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, Olivia’s is always there to feed your family. The menu is a nice mix of Southern comfort food with a few tropical twists. Our team picked up some dinner to go, ordering the Southernmost Buttermilk Chicken and Conch Fritters. Both were packed up nicely each in to-go boxes. The food would hold up well if traveling back to your Old Key West villa, or even to another Disney resort.

The Southernmost Buttermilk Chicken brings out the Southern side of the menu with mashed potatoes, Southern gravy, a biscuit, and green beans. The portion could be more than enough for one person, especially when paired with an appetizer. For $20.00 this entrée is a good value.

Enjoy Comfort Food with Olivia’s Take Out
Olivia’s Conch Fritters
Enjoy Comfort Food with Olivia’s Take Out
Olivia’s Southernmost Buttermilk Chicken

Conch Fritters are a Key West staple and showcase the island influence on the menu. The fritters were a little chewy, which is often the case with Conch Fritters, and have a mild onion flavor.  The highlight of this appetizer are the dipping sauces of Key Lime-Mustard and Roasted Pepper Remoulade. For $12.00 there are a decent value, and if you’re curious about conch they are a good way to introduce yourself.

To order to-go from Olivia’s just head to the small, but beloved Gurgling Suitcase Libations and Spirits. You can order from the full Olivia’s menu here to-go. Might as well grab yourself a tropical libation while you’re here too.

Looking for more Disney dining hidden gems? We’ve got ratings and reviews for every Disney restaurant, and other valuable tools to make your trip a breeze. Become a TouringPlans Subscriber and have access to all our helpful resources.

Have you ever dined at Olivia’s? Do you enjoy order Disney food to-go?

The post Enjoy Comfort Food with Olivia’s Take Out appeared first on Blog.

From our friends at
Filed Under: Dining, Disney Vacation Club, Observations, Resorts, disney dining, disney food review, disney food to go, Disney Resorts, Disney’s Old Key West Resort